The Upper Tribunal today handed down judgment in the case of Robin Crispin Odey v Financial Conduct Authority, in which Mr Odey sought to overturn the imposition of a lifetime prohibition on his performing any regulated activities and a significant financial penalty. 

The FCA alleged that Mr Odey was not a fit and proper person to perform regulated activities and that he had breached its Code of Conduct on five different bases: that he had twice used his power as majority owner of the AIFM in which he worked to remove the firm’s governing body (ExCo) on both occasions when it was due to conduct a disciplinary hearing into allegations that he had breached a Final Written Warning imposed upon him for prior misconduct towards female employees at the firm; that he had on both occasions substituted himself as the sole member of ExCo in reckless disregard of regulatory requirements of governance imposed upon the firm; that his conduct had risked entrenching a culture at the firm in which his behaviour towards female employees had become normalised and staff were reluctant to report their concerns; that he had made misleading statements to members of the firm, to investors and to the FCA as to his reasons for appointing himself sole member of ExCo; that he had made a false assertion of fact to the FCA in an attempt to obtain its endorsement of his plan indefinitely to postpone his disciplinary hearing.

The Upper Tribunal upheld all five of the FCA’s allegations and dismissed Mr Odey’s reference, rejecting his explanations for his behaviour as untrue, and finding that his account would not have been capable of justifying the extraordinary action he took, even if it had been true. The Tribunal endorsed the FCA’s interpretation of its own statutory jurisdiction to impose a financial penalty on Mr Odey for misconduct and rejected Mr Odey’s arguments that, because his dismissal of ExCo had been an exercise of his powers “as” a controller, his conduct fell outside the terms of ss.64A and 66 of FSMA.

Acknowledging that the case had not been about the question whether sexualised misconduct in the workplace was, of itself, a matter falling within the jurisdiction of the Authority to regulate, in handing down its judgment the Tribunal expressed its concern and extended its recognition to the women to whom Mr Odey accepted, in the course of the trial, he had caused emotional and other forms of harm.

Clare Sibson KC and Simon Paul acted for the FCA together with Lara Hassell-Hart of 4 Stone Buildings. The judgment may be found here.